Sefer Bereishit

Parshat Toldot: On the Dual Dimensions of Fear

By Rabbi Dr. Shmuly Yanklowitz

In Parshat Toldot, Genesis chapter 26, Isaac, despite a famine, is blessed by God with plentiful crops and wealth, which brings about envy among the Philistines among whom he lived. Avimelech, the Philistine king, consequently banishes Isaac from their land. 

At this point, Isaac needs to find a new home, so he travels to Beer Sheba. 1 This must have been a difficult situation for Isaac. Having had, in many ways, a contentious childhood, from the family tension between him and his older brother, Ishmael, to his nearly being sacrificed on Mount Moriah, we can imagine that Isaac, even as an adult, was prone to feeling scared and insecure. 

When Isaac is finding a new home while fleeing from the Philistines, the Torah tells us: 

That night the Lord appeared to him and said, “I am the God of your father Abraham’s [house]. Fear not, for I am with you, and I will bless you and increase your offspring for the sake of My servant Abraham.” 2

So he built an altar there and invoked the Lord by name. Isaac pitched his tent there and his servants started digging a well.

The medieval mystic Ramban, Nachmanides, notes specifically what Isaac was afraid of and further highlights the way in which God specifically told Isaac, “Fear not, for I am with you.” Nachmanides writes: 

Since Avimelech drove him away because of the Philistines’ jealousy of him, and since the herdsmen of Gerar quarreled with him, Isaac feared lest they gather against him and smite him and his family. Therefore, the Holy One be Blessed assured him that he should not fear them, and He blessed him. Then He prompted them so that the king went to Isaac with greater honor than that which he did to his father since he came with Phichol, the chief of his host, and also brought with him many of his friends. 3

From this passage we learn that the assurance that we have no need to be afraid comes directly from God. 

Fear is a theme that comes up throughout the Tanakh, and this makes sense. In an ancient world in which all people were vulnerable to violence and lacked the economic and technological comforts in which we find security today, fear was a major player in people’s lives. 

There is a peculiar phrase that shows up in our next parshah, Vayeitzei: “pachad Yitzhak,” “the fear of Isaac.” The context is when Isaac’s son Jacob, after receiving Divine restitution for stolen wages from his Uncle Laban, tells him: 

Had not the God of my father’s [house]—the God of Abraham and the Fear of Isaac—been with me, you would have sent me away empty-handed. But it was my plight and the toil of my hands that God took notice of and gave judgment on last night.” 4

So, in our parshah, Toldot, Isaac is encouraged not to fear. And yet, next week, the pachad Yitzhak, fear of Isaac, is a positive thing. This is because fear is something of a double-edged sword. Fear in the sense of awe – of God and creation – is necessary. It puts our lives into perspective and gives us the moral clarity to know when we’re obligated to take action in the world. 

At the same time, it is that same impulse that can lead us to mental paralysis. If we are afraid of all things all the time, we will not be able to carry out whatever our mission is in this life. 

Another phrase in the above-quoted passage (Genesis 26:24), and found often in the Torah, is “al tira,” “do not be afraid.” 5 We see it over and over in Deuteronomy, as we’re getting close to entering the land of Israel. The word tira is related to yirah, which has a dual meaning of fear and awe. Here, it’s used in the negative sense; it means fear. At the same time, our tradition heavily values yirat Shamayim, fear or awe of God, in the positive sense. 

One way of looking at all of this is by recognizing that our fear and awe should ideally not be directed toward anyone but God. While fearing humans often leads to poor decisions or even to indecision altogether, fear of God informs us as to how we ought to act. 

Another tactic for transitioning from fear to awe is to confront our fear and flip it toward an orientation of curiosity. Doing so can move us forward, toward a spiritual engagement with it.

We should not be overwhelmed by fear as Jews today, as we have zechut avot, the merit of our ancestors. This is precisely what God tells Isaac and Jacob. Through the stories of the Bible, we know that God is with us. By keeping that in mind, we should be able to turn down the temperature of our anxiety around survival. That does not mean we can be naïve and reckless, but it does mean that our primary purpose should be to fulfill our potential and do the work we’re called to do, rather than be stuck dwelling on fear for our individual and collective lives and continuity. 

Immediately following the Torah, in the Book of Joshua, as the Jews are about to enter the land of Israel, God twice tells Joshua, “hazak ve’ematz,” “be strong and courageous.” 6 This phrase is then repeated to Joshua by the Israelites themselves. We know not to be afraid because we know that, wherever we are, God is with us. 

And yet, our lives are often scary. Will we be safe? Will our loved ones be safe? Will we make it in our careers? Will we survive pandemics and accidents? Will cultural shifts lead toward hate-filled attacks? Will the perilous risks of climate change destroy us all? Will nuclear warfare leave none behind? In our minds, we’re molded from the times of people like Isaac, who faced deadly danger due to their enemies, to be hyper-focused on problems, the same way doctors and lawyers are trained to identify problems. 

But beyond our genetically determined, neural pathways, society, too, conditions us to be obsessed with the negative possibilities of our future. 

Rebbe Nachman of Breslov famously taught that “all the world is a very narrow bridge, but the main thing to recall is not to fear at all.” Rebbe Nachman does not mean that we should suppress our fear, but rather that if we zoom out to a higher spiritual consciousness and discover God’s presence, the fear is minimized, as a more spacious consciousness makes room for hope and holiness.

So too, leadership cannot operate from a fear-driven orientation. Fear is constrictive. It narrows the mind’s potential and the heart’s capacity to stretch. We need to lead from an expansive orientation.  

The lesson of much of the Torah is that fear is not the pathway to spiritual liberation. When we are restless in bed or unable during the day to carry out our work that needs to be done, we must know we can tap into the blessings of Isaac, which he merited for the Jewish people with his rightly placed fear. 

Like Isaac, we are not promised that everything we want will come about. Rather, we are promised that, if we are in awe of God, we will be blessed in our journey. 


Sources:

  1.  See Genesis 26:23
  2.  Genesis 26:24
  3.  Ramban on Genesis 26:24:1
  4.  Genesis 31:42
  5.  See Deuteronomy 1:21 and I Chronicles 28:20.
  6.  Joshua 1:6, 1:7, and 1:18.