Sefer Bereishit
Parshat Vayishlach: On the Importance of Food Laws
By Rabbi Dr. Shmuly Yanklowitz
Parshat Vayishlach is best-known for the scene in which Jacob wrestles with the angel and gets his new name, Israel. What often gets overlooked in this story, though, is the injury Jacob incurs in this encounter. The Book of Genesis mentions it almost in passing:
Jacob was left alone. And a figure wrestled with him until the break of dawn. When [the divine agent] saw that he had not prevailed against him, he wrenched Jacob’s hip at its socket, so that the socket of his hip was strained as he wrestled with him.
Then he said, “Let me go, for dawn is breaking.” But he answered, “I will not let you go, unless you bless me.”
Said the other, “What is your name?” He replied, “Jacob.”
Said he, “Your name shall no longer be Jacob, but Israel, for you have striven with beings divine and human and have prevailed.” 1
The detail about Jacob’s hip might seem extraneous and hardly relevant to the significance of the story. The Torah will soon explain the halachic, legal, meaning of this incident, as we will see.
But Rabbi Levi Yitzchak of Berditchev (18th-century Poland and Ukraine), in his mystical commentary Kedushat Levi, wrote of a symbolic dimension. He taught that Jacob’s feat here represented the convergence of “the three parts of the universe”: 2
- The angelic world
- The outer-space realm of the stars, planets, and galaxies
- The domain of animal life on earth 3
He explained that Jacob’s head represents the highest, angelic plane, which “enables him to recognize his Creator.” Next, his heart corresponds to the astronomical domain, the “world of wheels,” 4 which allows humanity to live by seasons and years, putting us in connection with the Creator. 5
“Finally,” he wrote, “the thighs [hip sockets] of the person represent the ‘lower universe,’ a domain in which God must be served by means of God’s creatures having faith in their Creator.6 Thighs are viewed as tools through which humanity is able to recognize the presence and power of a Creator. Thighs, or legs, also represent one’s habits and the risk associated habitual behavior, that man ends up serving God only from rote, lip service. 7
And we learn, just three verses after the wrestling bout, that, indeed, being Israel (as opposed to merely Yaakov) requires not mere lip service to God, but real-world action. The Torah continues:
The sun rose upon him as he passed Penuel, limping on his hip. That is why the children of Israel to this day do not eat the thigh muscle that is on the socket of the hip, since Jacob’s hip socket was wrenched at the thigh muscle. 8
Naturally, a debate in the Talmud ensues over what exactly the forbidden activity refers to. According to Rabbi Yehuda, “the thigh muscle” refers to the sciatic nerve of the right thigh. 9 Others, however, said this means the sciatic nerve on both thighs, and this became the prevailing opinion. 10
Still, people perplexed by the Torah’s non-rational traditions are probably asking, “Why?” Why turn this angelic encounter into a food law? Isn’t it enough that Jacob’s descendants and our entire people are called Israel, God-wrestlers, to remind us of this battle? After all, the common person eating only kosher food, unless they’re paying close attention to the Torah at the moment, isn’t going to know and realize the significance of what they’re eating or refraining from eating.
And so, commentators have come up with several explanations of what is going on with this commandment. One possibility, the Seforno posits, is that by refraining from eating the hip-socket, we demonstrate that, like Jacob, while we may be wounded by our enemies, we indeed can and will prevail over them. The damage was limiting, but at the same time insignificant, insofar as Jacob not only survived, but moved on and thrived. 11
Another proposition, by the Rashbam, is that we do not eat the thigh muscle “as a reminder of the heroism displayed by Yaakov, as well as a reminder of the miracle that God performed for him as a result of which he did not die.” 12
However, by studying this parshah, we can also learn that being called Israel and being mindful about how we eat are inseparable. Food ethics must be essential to our identity as Jews; the very moment we are named as a nation, when we are for the first time referred to as B’nei Yisrael, the Children of Israel, is ingrained with ethical food consciousness.
The Kli Yakar teaches us about the mystical dimensions involved in both this kashrut case and in the Garden of Eden, and in eating in general.
We find in [statements of] the Rabbis, may their memory be blessed, that deep things, the comprehension of which are difficult, are compared to tendons… And the hint in the prevention from eating the sciatic tendon for the generations is to be a commemoration that God prevented [the Israelites] from the fruit of the Tree of Knowledge, such that they not feed their minds things as difficult as tendons – as he [injured] the hollow of Jacob’s thigh. And if this setback temporarily occurred to the perfect Jacob when he veered a little from the even path, what will the ‘hyssop of the wall’ (average people), whose primary occupation is with the vanities of this world and its pleasures, do? Therefore they should not be occupied with hidden things, except for the special few, like R. Shimon Bar Yochai and his likeness… 13
We learn from the Book of Genesis to see the human body, yes, as one that connects to the Divine, but also as a part of the animal world. The thigh muscle of Yaakov was injured, and therefore we do not eat the thigh muscle of the animal.
Is this deducible by some sort of universal process of human reason, the same reason that teaches people not to murder or steal? Probably not. This commandment does, however, teach us something about what it means to be human.
True, kashrut laws help us develop empathy for animals. But even someone who’s never heard of keeping kosher could be called by morality and intuition to eat in a way that minimizes harm to animals. This specific commandment, though,
emphasizes the intersection of humanity, angels, and animals, and teaches us about the particular place of humans. We are not angels, able to do the will of God perfectly and on immediate command. So too, we are not merely animals,
who live not by conscience but by instinct.
In this Torah portion, Yaakov must learn to overcome not just the angel, but also the animal instinct to eat anything and everything a person pleases. And it is through the laws of kashrut and ethical eating that we learn to align
ourselves with our purpose as human beings.
Sources
- Genesis 32:25-29 The name Yisrael is derived from the words “sarita im Elokim v’im anashim vatuchal,” (“you have struggled with God and with man”).
- Kedushat Levi, Genesis, Vayishlach 6
- ibid.
- The “world of wheels” is rooted in the vision of Ezekiel (Ezekiel ch. 1) in which he describes, in detail and stunning imagery, his vision of angels surrounding God’s throne. The angels, as he depicts them, are accompanied by sets of wheels, enabling them to move freely in every direction.
- ibid.
- This calls to mind the expression “bowing at the thigh,” and indeed is part of the bowing procedure in the amidah prayer.
- Ibid.
- Genesis 32:32-33
- The text implies that Yaakov was only injured in one of his hip-sockets but does not specify which.
- Babylonian Talmud, Hulin 91a
- Seforno on Genesis 32:33 This understanding is based on the Midrash identifying the mysterious figure in this episode as the archangel of Eisav.
- Rashbam on Genesis 32:33
- Kli Yakar commentary on Genesis 32:33.